The political rally was winding down when the brash chief of a leftist South African occasion grabbed the microphone and started to stomp and chant. Hundreds of supporters joined in, and when he reached the climax, they pointed their fingers within the air like weapons.
“Kill the Boer!” Julius Malema chanted, referring to white farmers. The gang in a stadium in Johannesburg on Saturday roared again in approval.
A video clip of that second shot throughout the web and was seized upon by some People on the far proper, who stated that it was a name to violence. That notion actually took off when Elon Musk, the South African-born billionaire who left the nation as a teen, chimed in.
“They’re overtly pushing for genocide of white individuals in South Africa,” Mr. Musk, who’s white, wrote on Monday on Twitter, the platform he now controls.
Lately, individuals on the appropriate in South Africa and america, together with former President Donald J. Trump, have seized on assaults on white farmers to make the false declare that there have been mass killings.
Mr. Malema leads the Financial Freedom Fighters, a celebration that advocates taking white-owned land to offer to Black South Africans. That has made his embrace of the mantra all of the extra disturbing to some whites.
Regardless of the phrases, the music shouldn’t be taken as a literal name to violence, in line with Mr. Malema and veterans and historians of the anti-apartheid wrestle. It has been round for many years, one among many battle cries of the anti-apartheid motion that stay a defining function of the nation’s political tradition.
The mantra was born at a time when Black South Africans have been combating a violent, racist regime, and was made widespread within the early Nineteen Nineties by Peter Mokaba, a former youth chief within the African Nationwide Congress. However the A.N.C., the liberation occasion that has ruled South Africa for the reason that starting of multiracial democracy practically 30 years in the past, distanced itself from the music in 2012 — the identical 12 months it expelled Mr. Malema for his incendiary statements.
Bongani Ngqulunga, who teaches politics on the College of Johannesburg, recalled wrestle songs from the apartheid days during which individuals proclaimed they have been going to march to Pretoria, the capital metropolis, or that Nelson Mandela could be launched from jail the subsequent morning. The individuals singing these songs weren’t really planning to march to Pretoria, nor did they actually suppose that Mr. Mandela was about to be launched, he stated.
Equally, he stated, the phrase “kill the Boer” — the phrase means farmer in Dutch and Afrikaans — just isn’t meant to advertise violence in opposition to particular person farmers. “It was a name to mobilize in opposition to an oppressive system,” Mr. Ngqulunga stated.
Nomalanga Mkhize, a historian at Nelson Mandela College, stated of the mantra: “Younger individuals really feel that it rouses them up after they sing it immediately. I don’t suppose that they intend it to imply any hurt.”
However John Steenhuisen, the white chief of the Democratic Alliance, South Africa’s most important opposition occasion, filed costs this week in opposition to Mr. Malema on the United Nations Human Rights Council, and claimed, with out offering proof, that “brutal farm murders proceed to escalate within the wake of Malema’s demagoguery.”
Analysts say that Mr. Steenhuisen is raring to placate white South Africans, who is likely to be interested in events to his proper, forward of elections subsequent 12 months.
Mr. Malema, who thrives on provocation, projected a blasé angle towards the criticism. “Carry it on small boy,” he wrote in a Tweet to Mr. Steenhuisen.
Requested throughout a information convention on Wednesday about Mr. Musk’s remark, Mr. Malema responded: “Why should I educate Elon Musk? He appears to be like like an illiterate. The one factor that protects him is his white pores and skin.”
Mr. Malema emphasised a court docket ruling final 12 months that stated he was inside his rights to chant “kill the Boer.”
“I’ll sing this music as and once I really feel like,” he stated.
Simply over a decade in the past, a South African choose dominated that the music was hate speech and prohibited Mr. Malema, then the chief of the A.N.C. youth league, from singing it. However after being booted from the occasion and founding the E.F.F., Mr. Malema sang the music publicly once more.
AfriForum, a company that advocates for the pursuits of Afrikaners, descendants of South Africa’s white colonizers, took Mr. Malema to court docket.
Final 12 months, Choose Edwin Molahlehi dominated that AfriForum had “failed to indicate that the lyrics within the songs might moderately be construed to display a transparent intention to hurt or incite to hurt and propagate hatred.”
“Earlier than democracy, the music was directed on the apartheid regime,” he added, “and extra significantly to the dispossession of the land of the vast majority of the members of the society by the colonial powers.”
Mr. Malema testified throughout that court docket continuing that the lyrics shouldn’t be interpreted actually. The music, he informed the court docket, was directed towards the federal government’s failure to handle a disparity in land possession between Black and white South Africans.